FLS criticises ODPP | Calls public disclosure of DPP allegations ‘highly unusual’ - Voice of Asia

Fiji Law Society (FLS) President, Wylie Clarke, stated that it was "highly unusual" for an institution like the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) to issue an official statement regarding recent complaints against the Director of Public Prosecutions. He noted that the Law Society was deeply concerned about the media statement but would refrain from commenting further as the complaints must be properly investigated.

Mr. Clarke stated that the ODPP’s statement named the Director of Public Prosecutions, Christopher Pryde, and detailed the allegations made against him. He emphasized that these were merely allegations and that the investigation had only just begun. “It is possible that no charges will be laid,” he said. He argued that publicly airing allegations of misconduct against an individual, especially when these allegations have attracted media attention, prejudices that person's right to a fair trial and also violates their right to privacy.

Mr. Clarke further explained that a cornerstone of the criminal justice system and the rule of law is the right of an individual not to be identified, and for allegations against them to remain confidential, prior to criminal charges being laid in a court of law. He stressed that all individuals are presumed innocent, and the ODPP must protect, not undermine, those rights. He also stated that public confidence was further eroded when a senior prosecutor at the ODPP commented on social media, implying that the outcome of the Fiji Independent Commission Against Corruption (FICAC) investigation was a foregone conclusion and that Mr. Pryde would be charged.

In response, the ODPP issued a statement saying that it was not rare or unusual for it to issue media statements regarding complaints received or the progress of cases. The statement also gave assurances that the ODPP would respect the FICAC investigation process and the decision of the President. “We remain committed to the rule of law and the integrity of this office, including our public duty to report matters that may involve criminal offenses.”

The ODPP stated that they expect Mr. Pryde to return to work next Monday. The statement concluded by emphasizing their respect for legal processes and their commitment to the integrity of the office.